The Montrose Monitor reported in 1883 that "Mr. J.R. Kennedy became the first Superintendent, while his wife was the first Matron. Through the Nine years they managed the Institute, it has grown from a school with an attendance of a dozen little half-wild children, to an institution of learning, where nearly fifty children and young person were taught during the recent term. A large number of young person, who have been educated and taught some trade or employment by which they are now independent, are enabled to support themselves. The institution is doing grand work."
In 1883, Superintendent Failor resigned after being charged with firing a pistol at one of the boys. He fled the state instead of standing trial. The boy was David Wolpert, who says, "I was shot at by one of the Superintendents, who came after Mr. Kennedy for the crime of complaining about the unbearable conditions which prevail. The bullet grazed my right ear, but I'm glad to say it was the beginning of real and lasting improvements in the organization of the School. The would-be-homicidal Superintendent was removed, and the great educator, David Dudley (Superintendent from 1884-1899), took charge. I graduated in 1889, together with Mr. Paul Hubbard (later to be known for inventing the football huddle), and Miss Grace Young, who eight years later became Mrs. Wolpert. The three of us formed the first class to graduate from the School."
Anna O. Whitcomb was the first female Superintendent and in total, the third Superintendent of the school, appointed February 1884. In the late 1800's as a single lady, she was given a difficult time by those who thought she should not be in her position. In the summer of 1884, she considered leaving her position, and sent a letter to a board member describing her feelings. "Even Mrs. Failor (the previous Superintendent's wife), though protected by her husband, was defamed so much, the ladies of her own church would not call on her. I do not feel comfortable leaving the institute, but I think it is the best thing for me." She resigned her job, after one year, March 1885. A written school statement says, "Mrs. Whitcomb, having tired of the unsought honors that had been thrust upon her, delegated all her powers as Superintendent to the principal, David Dudley."
Superintendent Dudley, experienced as a teacher of the deaf and a former superintendent, began as a principal, November 1884, and progressed then to Superintendent, June 1885. During his first summer, Superintendent Dudley traveled thru the State of Colorado searching for mute or blind children who had not yet attended school. He resigned in 1887 due to continued ill health.
Superintendent Ray, a former teacher of the deaf, arrived from North Carolina and rented a cottage west on Kiowa. He began as Superintendent in December 1887 and worked in that position for nearly seven years. During his time at CSDB, the student population grew to 130, the facilities increased from one building to five and the name changed from the Colorado School Mute and Blind Institute (1884) to the Colorado School for the Deaf and the Blind (1893). After seven years as superintendent, Mr. Ray resigned to become superintendent of the Kentucky School.
In the meantime, Mr. Dudley, having regained his health and been appointed head teacher in the school and upon Mr. Ray's retirement again became superintendent. He continued in office until 1899, when ill health forced him to relinquish the position, and his death occurred some months later.
Mr. W.K. Argo, also form the Kentucky school, succeeded to the superintendent, March 1899, leading to 19 years of growth and increased efficiency of the school including new and remodeled buildings, health-promoting outdoor recreation for the students, and a well-stocked library. Agro, and his wife, Isabell "Bella", had worked as teachers in the Deaf department, beginning in 1896. They were favorites of the students, often leading students on excursions and hosting holiday parties. Mrs. Argo soon received a promotion as Matron of the residential program. Mr. Argo was superintendent until his death in 1921. Mrs. Argo became the next superintendent for one year until passing from ill health.
In 1922, Dr. Thomas S. McAloney was appointed the Superintendent of CSDB, succeeding the late Mrs. Argo. He remained at CSDB for 10 years and then, ill for only one day, Dr. McAloney died from peritonitis in 1932. At the time, he was the president of the American Association of Instructors for the Deaf. The Colorado Index reported, "He was devoted heart and soul to his students and brought to his work enthusiasm for progress that achieved results little short of miracles. There are buildings at several schools serving as monuments to his energy and efforts, but his greater monuments are found in the lives and characters of the many boys and girls who came under his care. He made the world a better place in which to live.
Mr. Alfred Brown, CSDB teacher and coach in 1912, soon became the School for the Deaf Principal and finally CSDB's Superintendent for 22 years beginning 1932 until 1954. In 1941, the Old Girls Hall was torn down and a new residential building was completed on the same site. "This is a very substantial building of stone construction and is one of the finest we have on the campus." In 1946, this building was named Alfred L. Brown Hall. During his time at CSDB, the Old School Building burned down and a new one, the Gottlieb Building, was built. He was also nationally known for training students who were deaf in square dancing, using American Sign Language to sign the calls.